Culture & change
Culture cannot be imposed by decree
Why mission statements change little as long as the unwritten rules remain in place

A company declares trust to be one of its core values. The new culture is meant to be open, respectful and courageous. Employees are given a presentation, there are workshops and posters hang in the entrance area. A few weeks later, critical feedback within the management team is described as a lack of loyalty. Anyone who acts on the new value finds themselves at a disadvantage.
What culture does the company actually have?
The answer does not come from the poster. It comes from how the feedback was handled. People learn from what happens in their everyday working lives. They observe which behaviour is recognised, which rules apply when in doubt and which exceptions are tolerated.
That is why culture cannot simply be imposed by a declaration. This does not mean, however, that leadership has no influence on culture. On the contrary: it is precisely the everyday decisions of managers that shape which rules people consider truly binding.
Culture does not begin in the workshop
Every organisation has a culture, even if it has never talked about it. People develop expectations about how collaboration works. They learn whom it is better to ask first when problems arise, what information to disclose in meetings and how decisions are actually made.
New employees often grasp surprisingly quickly which official rules are relativised in everyday practice. Perhaps the mission statement says that acting on one's own responsibility is desired. In practice, however, every small deviation has to be approved across several levels. Or collaboration is praised while bonuses reward individual results exclusively.
Such contradictions do not need to be explained explicitly. They are experienced. Repeated experiences create an expectation: what counts here is not necessarily what is said, but what actually has consequences.
This pattern is neither fundamentally good nor bad. It describes why culture runs much deeper than a jointly formulated statement of values.
Three levels we should keep apart
The organisational researcher Edgar Schein described how culture can be viewed on different levels. Visible first are things such as rituals, spaces, manners and documents. A second level consists of the declared values and principles. Behind these there are often barely spoken assumptions about how the world and collaboration work.
A company can present open-plan offices, a first-name culture and short decision paths. These are visible signals. At the same time it can declare that every person should take responsibility. Yet the unspoken assumption could be: important mistakes must under no circumstances become visible, otherwise the person responsible loses standing.
This assumption may well shape behaviour more strongly than the official mission statement. People will report problems late, avoid risky decisions or define responsibilities in such a way that nobody is clearly accountable.
Anyone who wants to change culture must therefore do more than swap visible signals. They must recognise the assumptions behind recurring patterns of behaviour.
Culture shows itself in the exceptions
A company can emphasise integrity. The value becomes decisive when an economically important customer demands a questionable course of action. Is the line then held, even though sales could be lost? Or does a justification for special treatment suddenly appear?
The same applies to respect. A manager can be polite in everyday dealings. But how does he behave when an employee makes a significant mistake? Is what happened examined objectively, or is the person publicly humiliated?
I consider such moments essential. Culture is not shaped only by what happens in normal situations. It becomes visible at the points where values cost money, reputation or time.
A value that only applies as long as it is convenient will soon be perceived by people as non-binding.
Incentives speak a language of their own
Sometimes an organisation demands behaviour that it simultaneously penalises. It calls for collaboration but rewards only the performance of individual teams. It expects early reporting of risks but judges projects mainly by whether they meet the originally communicated deadlines. It calls for a willingness to learn but leaves hardly any time for training.
Such tensions cannot be resolved by an additional training course. People act within a system of goals, resources and consequences. If the system favours a particular behaviour, an appeal to culture alone will change little.
Take a company that emphasises customer focus. Customer service staff, however, are measured mainly by the number of cases closed. A complicated customer case needs careful clarification but worsens the individual's key figure. The incentive runs counter to the declared customer focus.
The cultural question here is not: how do we motivate employees more strongly for the customer? It is: what effect do our goals and steering mechanisms produce? As long as this contradiction persists, the employees' behaviour may be entirely rational.
Leadership cannot simply delegate culture
Many organisations treat cultural change as a task for the HR department. HR organises workshops, supports values processes and produces communication material. That can be helpful. But responsibility for the rules that are actually lived remains with the people who make decisions and set consequences.
If the executive board calls for openness in a culture programme but at the same time disparages critical voices within its own leadership circle, it sends a clearer message than any event. If divisional heads demand collaboration but withhold information, corresponding patterns emerge in their teams too.
Leadership must therefore make its own decisions the subject of culture work. Which conflicts were decided in recent months, and how? Which behaviours have we rewarded? Which undesirable exceptions have we accepted because they were useful in the short term?
These questions are demanding because they do not concern only the employees. They are directed at the people who have control over structures and resources.
Change begins with observable behaviour
I would not begin cultural change with a wish list. First we should identify a concrete pattern that hinders important results. Perhaps mistakes are reported too late. Perhaps decisions get stuck between departments. Perhaps people quietly quit because their suggestions are never answered.
Then the task is to examine the situation carefully. Where does the behaviour show itself? Under what conditions? What consequences does it have for customers, employees and collaboration? Which existing rules make it likely?
Only then is it worth defining a desired behaviour. For example: critical project risks are raised within an agreed period, regardless of how unpleasant the message is. Or: every cross-departmental request is given a clearly named person responsible for the decision.
Statements like these can be tested in everyday practice. They also open up the possibility of adjusting the structures that have encouraged the previous behaviour.
Why symbolic actions still matter
It would also be too simple to dismiss all culture events, rituals and visible signs. People need shared experiences. A well-designed conversation can build trust. A new way of discussing successes and mistakes can make it visible that something is genuinely changing.
But symbolic actions gain their meaning from their context. A manager who openly admits a mistake and then makes the correction possible sends a different signal from a presentation featuring the term "error culture".
A ritual can support the new attitude. But it cannot replace it. What matters is whether it remains consistent with the other decisions.
The same applies to language. Terms such as agile, innovative, open or human-centred only acquire meaning when people know what concrete behaviour is associated with them and which previous practices no longer apply.
Resistance is not always a culture problem
When people resist change, their attitude is often criticised. They are said to be complacent, negative or unwilling to learn new things. That may play a role in individual cases. But before we pass such judgements, we should examine the change itself.
Perhaps it has been poorly explained. Perhaps it changes working conditions without the people affected having been involved. Perhaps it requires new skills for which there is no time. Or it shifts responsibility without adjusting decision-making authority.
Resistance can be a protective reaction, a factual objection or an indication of a gap in the design of the change. Labelling it across the board as a culture problem spares leadership an uncomfortable examination.
A good organisation should distinguish between well-founded criticism and refusal to fulfil agreed obligations. It needs openness to counter-arguments and, after a fair decision, commitment as well.
Culture changes through repeated consistency
A one-off measure will rarely be enough. People have reasons to trust the existing rules of behaviour: they have experienced that these rules work, at least for avoiding conflicts or protecting their own position.
New rules must therefore be confirmed repeatedly. When a mistake is reported openly, the reaction must not depend randomly on the manager's mood. When a team takes on a responsibility, it must be able to count on the corresponding resources. When a conflict is decided objectively, those involved should be able to understand the decision and its reasoning.
Only through such recurring experiences does a different expectation emerge about how one can act in the organisation.
Culture must not be misunderstood as an individual project of re-education. An organisation cannot simply reprogram people. It can shape the framework conditions, set good examples and correct incompatible behaviour to a limited extent. How people experience this and whether trust grows from it remains a social process.
What can actually be measured
Culture cannot be fully reduced to key figures. Nevertheless, changes should not be judged only at the level of mood. One can observe whether risks are raised earlier, whether decisions are more clearly assigned, whether employees report deviations and whether agreed consequences actually apply.
Employee surveys can complement what becomes visible in work processes. But they are no substitute for conversation. A high score in a culture questionnaire says little if important problems are systematically ignored elsewhere.
The observation must also be fair. Anyone who measures cultural change by how often employees raise objections must not automatically assume that more reports mean a worse culture. They could equally be a sign that problems are becoming visible for the first time.
Culture does not change at the same pace everywhere
An organisation often consists of different subcultures. What is taken for granted in a development team may be judged quite differently in sales or in a regulated operational function. A uniform mission statement does not automatically remove these differences.
This need not be a problem. A safety function needs different review and escalation paths from a team that tries out new ideas. Nevertheless, shared principles should remain recognisable: respect, comprehensible decisions and the responsible handling of mistakes must not depend on which department someone works in.
Anyone who takes culture work seriously will therefore not look only at an average value. They will examine differences between areas and ask whether these are objectively justified or an expression of contradictory structures of power and incentives. Change does not mean making everyone act the same way. It means making the essential rules reliable.
The decisive yardstick
I would not measure a culture initiative by how enthusiastic the launch event was. What interests me is what happens differently six months later in a difficult everyday situation. Is an uncomfortable truth spoken? Is a conflict of goals actually decided? Does a manager keep to a promised limit even when it costs them something?
Culture is not what we say about ourselves. Culture shows itself in what people in our organisation can actually expect.
That is why culture cannot be imposed by decree. But one can take responsibility for the conditions under which it develops. That is exactly where its change begins.