Back to articles

Thinking space

After the meeting, people speak plainly. Why not during it?

An example: after the meeting, the difficulties are discussed openly. During the meeting, the same concerns went unspoken.

The example is not a described individual case. It shows a difference that can be observed. It does not yet explain why people stayed silent.

Possible explanations

The moment was not recognisable: Perhaps there was no point at which a remark fitted in, or the meeting was timed so tightly that no room was left for objections.

Earlier remarks were dismissed: Perhaps someone has raised something before and found that the remark was brushed aside or turned against the person.

It is unclear who could change anything: Anyone who does not know who is responsible often does not raise a problem at all.

The assessment differs: It may also be that those involved do not judge in the same way whether there is a problem at all.

Each of these explanations is possible. Which one applies can only be tested in the specific case.

Separating observation and interpretation

It helps to separate a concrete observation from its interpretation. A commitment was postponed twice: that can be checked. The claim that someone does not take their responsibility seriously, by contrast, already assumes a cause.

A question that can be discussed would be: What precondition is missing for the commitment to be kept? This opens a matter to joint examination without prematurely pinning it on a person.

How an uncomfortable remark is received

Leadership also shows itself here in how an uncomfortable remark is received. Is it examined first, or defended against immediately? From this, those involved can infer whether disagreement is welcome in the next conversation.

Not every observation calls for a public airing

Relationship, role and a suitable setting are part of the weighing up. Some things belong in a one-to-one conversation, some in the meeting. Not every personal assessment has to be raised. Relevant risks, however, need a suitable reporting channel.

The question that takes this further is therefore: What would need to be in place for such a remark to be discussed in our meeting?

What is established? Whether concerns were voiced after the meeting but not in it can be observed in the specific case. What is a hypothesis? Why that is so. A helpful question asks first under what conditions a remark becomes possible, and only then who should have made it.

Thinking further: You will find more on the topic under Collaboration and leadership and in the book in chapter 12 "Decision culture". If the question in your organisation is how uncomfortable remarks can be made discussable, Coaching and enablement accompanies that path. A related question from everyday life is covered in the article on bad breath.

Context: The explanations given are possible causes, not a statistical statement and not a diagnosis of an organisation. The article is a practical aid to reflection.

Related insights